Email Marketing Agencies in Indiana

42 email marketing agencies are listed in Indiana. 35 have been assessed on the Agency List Score as of October 2026; the highest-ranked is Valve+Meter at 98.1.

Ranked · 28 of 35 assessed

Ordered by Agency List Score
#1 of 35 assessed
Valve+Meter
98

Math-first marketing and lead tracking built for home service brands

Ads ManagementContent MarketingConversion Rate Optimization
#2 of 35 assessed
Mediaura
97

Digital marketing and compliance-ready campaigns for healthcare and multi-location brands

Email MarketingLead GenerationMarketing Automation
#3 of 35 assessed
Firebelly Marketing
97

Creating meaningful social connections through content and management

Content MarketingEmail MarketingSocial Media Management (SMM)
#4 of 35 assessed
Oswald Marketing
96

Media buying, brand campaigns, and video production across broadcast, streaming, and social

Analytics & ReportingEmail MarketingSearch Engine Optimization
#5 of 35 assessed
LK Marketing
96

Customized multichannel marketing with personalized outreach and analytics

Email MarketingLanding PagesLead Generation
#6 of 35 assessed
The Plaid Agency
94

Crafts engaging content and strategic brand storytelling

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#7 of 35 assessed
D2stechnologies
92

SEO and PPC services for inbound lead capture and search visibility

Analytics & ReportingContent MarketingEmail Marketing
#8 of 35 assessed
Digitable
78
Verified

Enhancing online presence with SEO and digital advertising expertise

Email MarketingSearch Engine OptimizationSocial Media Management (SMM)
#9 of 35 assessed
AimFire Marketing
74

SEO and search services for inbound lead capture and search visibility

Content MarketingEmail MarketingSocial Media Management (SMM)
#10 of 35 assessed
Buckaroo Marketing
73

B2B marketing solutions for manufacturers and industrial brands

Email MarketingWebsite Optimization
#10 of 35 assessed
Business Art DeSigns
73

Custom interior and exterior signage from an independently owned creative studio

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#12 of 35 assessed
Importynt AI Digital Agency
73

AI-driven digital marketing for SMBs leveraging SEO and PPC

Email MarketingReputation ManagementSearch Engine Optimization
#13 of 35 assessed
Thrive Marketing Strategies
73

Strategy-first marketing for businesses and non-profits

Email MarketingSocial Media Management (SMM)Website Optimization
#14 of 35 assessed
Indy Digital Marketing Solutions
73

Affordable websites, SEO, and Google Ads for small businesses

Email MarketingReputation ManagementSearch Engine Optimization
#15 of 35 assessed
Britton Marketing & Design Group
73

Branding and marketing for the New American Middle

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#16 of 35 assessed
To-A-Tee
73

Custom screen printing and embroidery with fast fulfillment

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#17 of 35 assessed
SteerPoint
73

AI-enhanced PPC and SEO for measurable growth

Email MarketingMarketing AutomationSearch Engine Optimization
#17 of 35 assessed
Andronesi
73

Database-driven websites, mobile apps, and branding built for Algarve businesses

Email MarketingSearch Engine OptimizationSocial Media Management (SMM)
#19 of 35 assessed
Porch Light Public Relations
73

Media relations and content creation for brand awareness

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#20 of 35 assessed
MediaFuel
73

Creates captivating videos and strategic marketing campaigns

Ads ManagementContent MarketingEmail Marketing
#21 of 35 assessed
Matchbook Marketing
72

Ignites brands with strategy, creative design, and advertising.

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#22 of 35 assessed
Willow Marketing
72

Balancing strategy and creativity for impactful marketing results

Ads ManagementAnalytics & ReportingContent Marketing
#23 of 35 assessed
Circle City Digital
71

Custom website design and long-term digital strategy for Central Indiana businesses

Content MarketingEmail MarketingSearch Engine Optimization
#24 of 35 assessed
Moonflower Marketing
65
Verified

Clear messaging and strategy for professional services growth

Content MarketingEmail MarketingLanding Pages

Also in Indiana · 14 not ranked here

7 have not yet been assessed on the Agency List Score. Alphabetical.

About this ranking

What this page ranks

This page ranks 28 of the 35 assessed email marketing agencies in Indiana — the ones carrying a published score — out of 42 listed.

The score measures how well an agency documents its own work in public — named clients, quantified outcomes, and whether those outcomes are attributed to the agency rather than described as the client's own results. It does not measure client satisfaction, price, or availability.

Cohorts and awards

Agencies are compared within a cohort — here, Email Marketing in Indiana. A cohort must be large enough to express the band being awarded: at least 8 assessed agencies for a top 25% award, 20 for top 10%, 40 for top 5%, and 300 for top 1%. This one holds 35, so the strongest award available here is top 10%.

The 7 email marketing agencies not yet assessed are listed on this page but not ranked.

A further 7 were assessed and no published evidence of their work was found, so no score is shown for them.

Read the full methodology

Paid placement

Partner agencies can buy a labelled placement block above the ranking on this page. It is always marked as paid and is never mixed into the ranked list.

Placement is paid; it does not affect the ranking, cohort membership, or any agency's score. Ranking position, cohort membership and the score itself are not for sale.

Browse

Questions

How many email marketing agencies are in Indiana?
42 are listed on Agency List in Indiana. 35 of them have been assessed on the Agency List Score as of October 2026, and 28 of those carry a published score.
Which email marketing agency in Indiana is ranked highest?
Valve+Meter, with an Agency List Score of 98.1, ranks #1 of 35 assessed agencies in Email Marketing in Indiana.
Why are 14 email marketing agencies listed here but not ranked?
7 of the 42 listed have not yet been assessed on the Agency List Score. A further 7 were assessed and no published evidence of their work was found, so no score is shown for them. They each have a profile and are listed below the ranking, alphabetically, rather than being hidden or mixed into it.
How is the ranking determined?
By Agency List Score, within the Email Marketing in Indiana cohort of 35 assessed agencies. The score is computed from evidence published on each agency's own website: named clients, quantified outcomes, and whether the outcome is attributed to the agency. Paid placement does not affect it.